Thanksgiving is synonymous with a unifying meal shared with loved ones. Traditional dishes such as mashed potatoes, pumpkin pie, and, most famously, turkey takes center stage on this day of gratitude. But when did turkey earn its place as the holiday’s undisputed star?
The story begins in the 19th century when Plymouth settlers discovered the lands were teeming with turkeys. The birds quickly became a popular meal choice because they were abundant, easy to butcher, and could feed a crowd.
However, it was Sarah Josepha Hale who cemented turkey’s iconic status. In her 1827 novel Northwood, Hale devoted an entire chapter to describing a New England Thanksgiving, prominently featuring a roasted turkey “at the head of the table.” By 1870, when Thanksgiving was officially recognized as a national holiday, the turkey had become entrenched in American tradition.
The turkey’s place in the spotlight has endured but isn’t without competition. A recent survey of Knights revealed that most stick with turkey, considering it a classic and traditional choice. However, some Knights opt for ham—or even both—at their Thanksgiving feasts.
Ham enthusiasts cite its juicy flavor as a significant draw, noting that pork offers a less dry alternative to turkey. While ham may win on taste for some, turkey boasts a unique advantage: it contains tryptophan, an amino acid that increases serotonin production. This “feel-good” hormone promotes relaxation and often leads to the quintessential post-Thanksgiving nap.
For many, turkey’s sentimental value and versatility seal its supremacy. “Ham doesn’t pair as well with gravy or the rest of the dishes,” noted one passionate Knight. Others argue that ham simply can’t replicate the cozy, comatose feeling turkey provides after dinner.
Whether your Thanksgiving table features turkey, ham, or both, the holiday is about more than just the main course. It’s a time to bring loved ones together and indulge in a meal that satisfies everyone’s cravings. So, Knights, which protein will you choose to celebrate this year?
